You've probably seen recipes that suggest cooking onions for around five minutes, but then, five minutes goes by and they're still crunchy, pale, and nowhere close to caramelized.
According to chef Tom DeRosa, associate professor in the College of Food Innovation & Technology at Johnson & Wales University in Charlotte, North Carolina, that's because onions need more time than most people realize and trying to rush them usually does not end well.
Why Onions Take So Long To Cook
The biggest reason onions take so long to cook is that they are mostly water.
"Many home cooks underestimate just how much water onions contain—often close to 90%," DeRosa tells Southern Living. "Before onions can truly soften and begin to brown, much of that moisture must evaporate, and that just takes time."
How long that takes depends on the type of onion, the size of your pan, how thick you've sliced them, and the heat you're using.
Softened Vs. Caramelized Onions
DeRosa says one of the biggest misconceptions is that sautéed onions and caramelized onions are the same thing.
"People often confuse sautéing with caramelizing," DeRosa explains. "Softening sliced onions may take eight to 12 minutes, but developing the deep golden color and rich, sweet flavor associated with caramelized onions can easily take 30 to 45 minutes, sometimes longer depending on the quantity, the pan, and the heat level."
Mistakes That Will Slow The Process
DeRosa says the biggest mistake people make is trying to cook onions faster.
"I recommend thinking of onions as an ingredient that rewards patience," he says. "Trying to rush the process with high heat usually leads to browned or burned edges while the inside of the onion is still firm."
The North Carolina-based chef says other mistakes people make when cooking onions include:
Too much heat. "High heat may seem like a shortcut, but it often causes the onions to scorch before they've had enough time to release their moisture and naturally caramelize," he says.
Overcrowding the pan. "A pan that's too full traps steam, causing the onions to soften instead of brown. Using a wide skillet gives moisture a chance to evaporate, which is essential for developing good color and flavor," DeRosa explains.
Cutting thick wedges. "Thinly sliced onions cook much more quickly than thick slices or wedges, so cooking times are always estimates rather than exact rules," he says.
Stop cooking too soon. "Once onions become translucent, they're softened, but they're not caramelized. True caramelization takes considerably longer and develops a much richer flavor," DeRosa explains.
How To Know When Onions Are Done
The right stopping point depends on your recipe. For soups, sauces, and many sautéed dishes, onions are ready once they're soft, translucent, and no longer have a raw bite. For dishes like French onion soup, onion jam, or deeply flavored sauces, keep cooking until the onions are evenly golden brown, very soft, and noticeably sweet.
"I always encourage home cooks to use both their eyes and their taste," DeRosa says. When the sharp bite is gone and the onions taste rich and sweet, they're ready.
Read the original article on Southern Living