Lifestyle

How a 1917 Marketing Campaign Made Marshmallow-Topped Sweet Potatoes a Thanksgiving Staple

How a 1917 Marketing Campaign Made Marshmallow-Topped Sweet Potatoes a Thanksgiving Staple
Image: yahoo.com

Every Thanksgiving, a familiar dish finds its way onto dinner tables across America: sweet potato casserole crowned with a layer of golden, toasted marshmallows. For some families, it's an essential holiday side. For others, the combination of a naturally sweet vegetable and a sugary topping raises an intriguing question: Is this really a side dish, or is it dessert in disguise? The answer is rooted in American food history, where culinary traditions have often emerged from unexpected places.

The history of marshmallows on sweet potatoes is more than a story about holiday cooking. It involves food manufacturers, changing tastes and the creative ways Americans have incorporated convenience foods into traditional meals. Long before marshmallows became a Thanksgiving staple, sweet potatoes were served roasted, mashed, glazed and baked into puddings. Their natural sweetness made them a versatile ingredient, particularly during the fall harvest season.

But adding marshmallows transformed the dish into something distinctly American. The combination of creamy sweet potatoes and gooey, toasted marshmallows creates a contrast of flavors and textures that still inspires both nostalgia and debate. Whether you prefer the classic marshmallow topping or a crunchy pecan streusel, understanding the dish's origins reveals how seemingly unconventional combinations can become beloved traditions.

So, why do we put marshmallows on sweet potatoes? The surprising answer involves a marketing campaign, the science of sweetness and the evolution of Thanksgiving sides. Here's what culinary historians and food experts reveal about this iconic holiday dish. Let's dig in.
The Surprising Marketing Stunt That Started It All (1917)
The origins of marshmallow-topped sweet potatoes are often traced to 1917, when Angelus Marshmallows commissioned Janet McKenzie Hill, founder of The Boston Cooking School Magazine, to develop recipes featuring its product. According to the Library of Congress, the resulting booklet included a recipe for sweet potatoes baked with a marshmallow topping, often cited as the earliest documented appearance of the combination.

The campaign aimed to persuade home cooks to use marshmallows as an ingredient rather than simply enjoy them as candy. It was a familiar strategy for the era.

As food historian Michael Krondl explains, "Just about every food manufacturer put out torrents of promotional recipes for their product." He points to chocolate chip cookies and green bean casserole—another Thanksgiving favorite—as examples of foods whose popularity was boosted by corporate recipe promotion (by Nestlé and Campbell's, respectively).

The Angelus booklet may have introduced the combination, but Krondl identifies an advertisement for Campfire Marshmallows in the December 1921 issue of American Cookery as an important milestone. The ad indicated that recipes were printed on every package. "So my guess is that they were the ones who popularized it," he says.

Angelus and Campfire merged in 1930, and the combined company continued distributing promotional cookbooks in the 1930s, giving the recipe additional exposure.

As Krondl observes, "All food traditions start somewhere; they have to be invented; it's just that ours often came out of corporate test kitchens."

Related: This Simple Sweet Potato Casserole Has Over 500 5-Star Reviews
Before Marshmallows: How Sweet Potatoes Were Served in the 1800s
Sweet potatoes were well established in American cooking long before marshmallow manufacturers saw an opportunity. Nineteenth-century cooks roasted, mashed, sweetened and incorporated them into puddings and other baked dishes.

Amelia Simmons' American Cookery, published in 1796 and recognized as the first American-authored cookbook, includes a potato pudding recipe combining sweet potatoes with milk and nutmeg. Eliza Leslie's Directions for Cookery, published in 1840, also features a sweet potato pudding.

Sweet potatoes have a particularly deep history in Southern cooking, shaped in part by enslaved Africans and their descendants. That history may also help explain why Americans often use the word yam for sweet potato, a practice Krondl connects to the African diaspora. "In Africa, so-called 'true yams' are a staple. These are tubers that may have had a superficial similarity to the American native."

True yams (Dioscorea) and sweet potatoes (Ipomoea batatas) are botanically distinct. Yet in the United States, orange-fleshed sweet potatoes are frequently labeled as yams, even though most grocery-store "yams" are actually sweet potatoes.

Incidentally, sweet potatoes were served at Thanksgiving before marshmallow-topped casseroles became familiar. An 1887 issue of Good Housekeeping included them on its Thanksgiving menu, suggesting their holiday presence extended beyond the South.
The Science of Sweetness: Why the Flavor Combination Works
Sweet potatoes and marshmallows work so well together for a reason. Their flavors complement each other, while their contrasting textures make every bite more interesting.

"Cooked sweet potatoes have earthy, sweet, sometimes caramel-like notes that go nicely with the vanilla and toasted-sugar flavors of marshmallows," says food science consultant Edmund McCormick.

Cooking also enhances the taste. As he explains, "Baking can also increase the potatoes' sweetness as enzymes convert some of their starch into maltose."

Texture plays an equally important role. McCormick describes the combination as "dense, creamy sweet potato beneath a light, gooey topping with a delicate toasted surface. The contrast is an important part of the pleasure."

The marshmallows themselves undergo an appealing transformation in the oven. "A conventional marshmallow is an edible foam, with tiny air bubbles held in a structure of sugar syrup and gelatin. Heat softens the structure, making the interior gooey, while the exposed surface loses moisture and develops a delicate crust," McCormick explains.

The browning involves both Maillard reactions and caramelization. Although these are different chemical processes, both contribute color and more complex aromas. "The result is a shift from straightforward sweetness toward toasted, caramel-like flavors," he says.

Related: The Secret Ingredient for the Easiest-Ever Sweet Potato Casserole
Sweet Potato Casserole vs. Candied Yams: What's the Difference?
People often use the terms sweet potato casserole and candied yams interchangeably, especially around Thanksgiving. However, they typically describe two different preparations.

Sweet potato casserole generally features cooked sweet potatoes that are mashed or puréed, seasoned and baked. The filling may include butter, milk or cream, and brown sugar, and a topping of marshmallows or a brown sugar-and-pecan streusel. The finished dish is soft and spoonable.

Candied sweet potatoes, commonly called candied yams in the United States, are typically made with sweet potatoes cut into chunks or slices and coated in a sweet glaze. Butter and brown sugar create a syrupy coating as the potatoes cook. The result is closer to glazed potato pieces than to a mashed casserole.

The distinction isn't always strict, however. Some candied-yam recipes include marshmallows, while some sweet potato casseroles feature pecans or no topping at all. As with many Thanksgiving dishes, family recipes often blur the lines.
Marshmallows vs. Pecan Streusel: The Great Thanksgiving Debate
For many Thanksgiving cooks, choosing a sweet potato casserole topping comes down to personal preference. Marshmallows provide a gooey, sweet topping, while pecan streusel adds crunch and buttery richness.

Acclaimed Southern chef Carla Hall explains the appeal of each: "Marshmallows bring that gooey sweetness, and when they're toasted, you get a little smokiness that adds another layer of flavor."

Pecan streusel, meanwhile, "brings crunch and texture, along with the deep, rich flavor of toasted nuts," she says.

McCormick points out that the nuts in a streusel "also contribute a little bitterness and a more substantial chew, which can make the sweetness feel less dominant.

But as Hall puts it, "Both are delicious, just different experiences!" So if your family can't agree, there's no reason you can't make both.
Tips for the Perfect Marshmallow Sweet Potato Topping
A few simple techniques can help prevent your sweet potato casserole from being watery, overly sweet or burnt.

Skip the canned sweet potatoes. Hall cautions that canned sweet potatoes often contain excess liquid, which can water down the flavor and leave you with a loose casserole.

Roast the potatoes. Hall recommends roasting sweet potatoes in their jackets to concentrate their natural sugars. If you do boil your spuds, McCormick recommends draining them thoroughly and letting excess steam escape before mashing.

Control moisture. Mash the potatoes while they're warm and add milk or cream gradually. McCormick explains, "You want a filling that holds a soft mound, rather than one that flows."

Get creative. Hall suggests adding ingredients such as orange zest, ginger, cinnamon or nutmeg to bring out the sweet potato's flavor without making the dish overly sweet.

Taste before sweetening. Since roasting concentrates the potatoes' natural sweetness, you may not need to use as much sugar as your recipe suggests. "Taste your sweet potatoes before adding sugar. Hall advises. "They may be sweeter than you think!"

Bake the filling first. One of the most common mistakes is adding marshmallows too early. The filling needs time to heat through, but marshmallows require only a short time to toast. "I like to add the marshmallows during the last 10 minutes of baking, once the casserole is already hot," she says.

Arrange the marshmallows in a single layer. This helps create a more evenly toasted surface rather than a thick, overly sticky topping.

Watch them closely: For a deeply toasted finish, a broiler can brown the marshmallows quickly, but Hall cautions, "Keep an eye on them because they can go from beautifully golden to burned in no time!"

Prepping ahead? Hold off on the marshmallows until after reheating the casserole. McCormick recommends adding the topping once the filling is hot to prevent the marshmallows from becoming overly sticky or collapsing into the potatoes.

This Thanksgiving classic reminds us that some of America's most beloved food traditions began with a little experimentation—and sometimes a clever marketing idea.

Next, 30 Must-Have Thanksgiving Sweet Potato Side Dishes To Please All Palates
Sources:
Carla Hall is an acclaimed chef, bestselling author and television personality (Top Chef and The Chew). Her latest cookbook, Carla Hall Bakes: Sweet, Savory and from the Heart (2026), celebrates her love of baking. Catch her these days on Fox's Next Level Baker and on YouTube, reunited with Michael Symon and Clinton Kelly on Chewed Up Show.

Edmund "Ed" McCormick is a food science consultant and ingredient specialist whose work focuses on the chemistry of taste, texture and functional food ingredients. He is the founder, primary author, scientific voice and educator behind Cape Crystal Brands. His next book, The Ingredient Insider: What Food Science Really Says About What We Eat, is slated for release later this year.

This story was originally published by Parade on Nov 22, 2026, where it first appeared in the Food & Drink section. Add Parade as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

Source: yahoo.com