When your refrigerator is packed with Thanksgiving food and you still need to make dessert, sometimes you have to get creative. Allrecipes Allstar Nicole Geldart's Nana had a particularly clever solution: She put bowls of Jell-O outside in the Canadian snow to set. It was all part of preparing her famous holiday trifle, a colorful, creamy dessert that became a centerpiece at family gatherings.
"I think it was just always present at holiday gatherings," Geldart says. "My grandma would usually host all the big Thanksgivings and Christmases."
Growing up in Mississauga, Ontario, Geldart looked forward to the dessert every holiday season. Her grandparents, who were born in Poland and lived in London before settling in Canada, brought plenty of European food traditions to the family table. Alongside homemade pierogi, kielbasa, and other favorites, Nana's trifle always had a place of honor.
A Beloved Holiday Tradition
Credit: Courtesy of Nicole Geldart
The dessert itself was a feast for the eyes, with layers of jelly roll cake, colorful Jell-O, fruit, creamy custard, and whipped topping piled high in a big glass bowl. Even after everyone had stuffed themselves with Thanksgiving dinner, there was always room for a scoop.
"It's just a showstopper," Geldart says. "Everyone gathers around the table. You're full from dinner, but it's still time for dessert."
Serving the trifle was a special honor in Geldart's family. She remembers her brother Adam having the coveted job a few times.
Today, Geldart's mom and aunts carry on the tradition, each putting their own spin on Nana's beloved dessert. While Nana never wrote down the recipe, Geldart pieced together the ingredients and instructions from family photos, her own memories, and conversations with other family members. The result is a wonderfully nostalgic, surprisingly easy dessert that deserves a place on more holiday tables.
How To Make Nana's Jell-O Trifle
Credit: Courtesy of Nicole Geldart
The beauty of Nana's trifle is that no baking is required, and most of the ingredients are ready to use. Plus, you can easily customize the layers with your favorite fruits and Jell-O flavors. Here's how to put it all together:
Start with the jelly roll. Slice one premade strawberry or raspberry jelly roll into rounds and arrange them along the bottom and sides of a large glass trifle bowl, with the pretty swirls facing outward. Add the fruity layers. Spoon a layer of cubed, prepared Jell-O over the cake, followed by fruit cocktail or fresh berries.
Bring on the custard. Spread a layer of prepared Bird's Custard over the fruit, followed by a generous layer of Cool Whip. Repeat the layers until you've used everything up.
Decorate and chill. Finish with a layer of Cool Whip, then arrange drained mandarin orange slices and maraschino cherries on top. Refrigerate until you're ready to serve.
Nana's Easy Holiday Trifle
Bird's Custard Powder—a British egg-free custard powder and dessert sauce—can be found in the European section of grocery stores, at World Market, and online.
Ingredients
1 premade strawberry or raspberry jelly roll
1 package prepared Jell-O, cubed
1 15-ounce can fruit cocktail, drained, or 1 cup of fresh berries
2 cups prepared Bird's Custard
1 8-ounce container Cool Whip
1 can mandarin oranges, drained
Maraschino cherries
Directions
Cut the jelly roll into 3/4-inch slices and line the bottom and sides of a trifle dish or large glass bowl with swirls facing outward.
Add a layer of prepared Jell-O over the jelly roll slices, then follow with a layer of fruit cocktail or fresh berries.
Spread the prepared custard over the fruit, then add a layer of Cool Whip.
Repeat with the remaining jelly roll slices, Jell-O, fruit, custard, and Cool Whip.
Decorate the final layer of Cool Whip with mandarin orange slices and maraschino cherries. Refrigerate until ready to serve.
Tips and Tricks
If using individual trifle dishes or glasses, cut the jelly roll into cubes and add one layer of each ingredient.
When making the Bird's Custard, cover the custard with plastic wrap so it doesn't form a skin as it cools.
Pick a Jell-O flavor and color to best match the fruits used and the holiday. For example, Nana would use both red and green Jell-O for her Christmas trifle.
Check the bakery section of your local grocery store for a premade strawberry or raspberry jelly roll. Geldart says Swiss cake rolls or pound cake also work well, so don't worry if you can't find the exact cake Nana used.
You probably won't need to set your Jell-O outside in the snow as Nana did, but that's part of the charm. It's easy to make your own, and who knows? Maybe one day your family will be telling stories about how you made it, too.
Read the original article on Allrecipes