Business

HBO Max and Paramount+ Bundle Faces Antitrust Lawsuit

HBO Max and Paramount+ Bundle Faces Antitrust Lawsuit
Image: finance.yahoo.com

Photo by Samuel Boivin/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Paramount's $110 billion takeover of Warner Bros. Discovery is already complete, but subscribers are heading back to court to challenge what happens next. A newly amended federal lawsuit targets the company's plans to bundle HBO Max and Paramount+, arguing that putting both streaming services under one owner could mean higher prices, fewer choices, and less competition.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, consumers refiled their antitrust complaint Thursday in federal court in California, seeking to unwind the blockbuster acquisition. The lawsuit points to a planned HBO Max and Paramount+ bundle arriving in early 2027 as evidence that Skydance is moving toward eliminating competition between two previously independent streaming platforms.

The argument is straightforward: Before the merger, customers unhappy with HBO Max could cancel and switch to Paramount+, or vice versa. Now, both services belong to the same company, even if they continue operating under separate names.

COMPLEX SHOP: Shop the brands you love, anytime and anywhere. Uncover what's next. Buy. Collect. Obsess.

Skydance's streaming services "may retain distinct names and interfaces, but both now answer to one owner and its combined financial interests," the complaint states.

The plaintiffs argue that the arrangement gives Skydance less incentive to compete against itself on subscription prices, exclusive programming, or customer value.

"The consumer may still choose between two brands, but no longer has the choice between those two independent sellers," the lawsuit states.

And Skydance executives haven't exactly hidden their plans to bring the platforms closer together.

"Long-term, the plan is basically to bring them together," CEO David Ellison said last month after Paramount completed its Warner Bros. Discovery acquisition on Oct. 6.

The streaming strategy is only one part of the lawsuit. Subscribers also cite the departures of James Gunn and Peter Safran from DC Studios and Skydance's aggressive cost-cutting plans as evidence of consolidation affecting the entertainment industry.

The company recently outlined plans to achieve at least $6 billion in annual savings through layoffs, real estate consolidation, increased reliance on artificial intelligence, and changes to its content operations.

That comes as Skydance manages nearly $80 billion in net debt following the merger, which combined Paramount Pictures, Warner Bros. Pictures, HBO, CBS, CNN, and numerous television networks under one corporate umbrella.

Ellison and co-CEO Ynon Kreiz have maintained that the combined company will continue spending approximately $30 billion annually on content.

"With the reach of our combined platforms across streaming, broadcast and cable, each title can work harder for us, and as one company we can make smarter choices about how we distribute and monetize our slate," the executives wrote.

But the subscribers challenging the merger contend that those efficiencies could come at consumers' expense.

Their complaint also alleges that Skydance's ownership of two major movie studios allows the company to coordinate theatrical release schedules that competing businesses would otherwise set. Similar concerns extend to national television news, where CBS News and CNN now share a corporate parent.

The legal challenge follows months of opposition to Paramount's acquisition, including an antitrust lawsuit brought by 12 state attorneys general and a separate challenge from the Writers Guild of America.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta previously argued that the merger would reduce competition, threaten entertainment jobs, and increase costs for consumers. Paramount ultimately reached separate settlements with the states and the Writers Guild of America, clearing the way for the acquisition to close.

Hollywood figures also opposed the deal. Mark Ruffalo publicly urged Bonta to reject a settlement, pointing to thousands of filmmakers who had signed petitions against the merger.

"Don't you dare, Rob Bonta, do not cave," Ruffalo wrote.

The latest lawsuit, however, faces a significant procedural obstacle. The court has already dismissed the subscribers' case twice, and the amended filing is believed to be their final opportunity to present a viable legal challenge.

Skydance did not respond to The Hollywood Reporter's request for comment.
Related Stories

Paramount Prepares to Take Over Warner Bros. Next Week as Executive Shake-Ups Begin

Mark Ruffalo Tells California AG 'Do Not Cave' as Paramount Reaches Warner Bros. Merger Settlement

Paramount Investor Accuses David and Larry Ellison of 'Illegal' Side Deal Tied to WBD Merger Related News
Frankie Muniz Rushed to Hospital After Crashing Race Car During Daytona Speedway Practice Lap

Exclusive: Here's When You Can Watch 'Rolling Loud: The Movie' at Home

COMPLEX SHOP: Shop the brands you love, anytime and anywhere. Uncover what's next. Buy. Collect. Obsess.

Making Culture Pop. Find the latest entertainment news and the best in music, pop culture, sneakers, style and original shows.

Source: finance.yahoo.com