Lifestyle

The Next Time You Make Pie Crust, Add This to the Water for the Flakiest Results

The Next Time You Make Pie Crust, Add This to the Water for the Flakiest Results
Image: yahoo.com

Kitchn and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article. Pricing and availability are subject to change.

Credit: Celia Funderburk

I come from a family that takes cooking shortcuts when we can. We serve premade mashed potatoes on Thanksgiving, use jarred marinara sauce for spaghetti night, and we always opt for a premade pie crust. Eliminating that extra step of making a pie crust by hand just makes the act of baking a pie or quiche that much more approachable. Lately, though, when I have the time, I have been starting to challenge my ingrained shortcut ways.

Pie crust, in particular, is one item that has intimidated me. Sometimes a homemade dough comes out too dry and crumbly, or it gets too sticky. But I just saw a trick on America's Test Kitchen's TikTok that made me want to try homemade pie dough again. It features a secret ingredient that is supposed to make an easier-to-roll-out pie crust. That ingredient? Sour cream.
How to Add Sour Cream to Pie Crust
Mix half of the butter with the flour. In the food processor, mix half of your sliced cold butter in with the flour, granulated sugar, and salt. Pulse until combined.

Combine sour cream and ice-cold water. Our pie crust recipe normally calls for 5 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon of ice-cold water. I swapped in 2 tablespoons of sour cream here and whisked to combine the sour cream with the water.

Add the sour cream mixture to the food processor. Pour the sour cream mixture into the food processor and sprinkle the remaining butter on top. Pulse until combined.

Form and chill. Transfer the dough onto a floured counter and form it into two discs. Wrap them each in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least an hour before rolling.

Credit: Celia Funderburk

My Honest Review of Adding Sour Cream to Pie Crust
Swapping sour cream for some of the water in your pie crust is meant to reduce the cracking you may get when rolling the dough out. The cold butter that pie crust recipes call for can be brittle and dry when mixed with the flour, which is the main reason the dough can crack. A lot of recipes (including ours) recommend adding ice-cold water to moisten the dough, but the video explains this can lead to another issue. When you mix in water on top of the other ingredients, you can overwork the dough and create too much gluten. This makes the crust tough, which is exactly why you see a lot of baking recipes in general say "be sure not to overmix."

This trick to add sour cream instead of just water worked wonderfully. It moistens the dough so it doesn't crack as easily, but also contains some fat so you're not just adding straight water to the crust. There definitely was still some cracking and tearing while I was rolling the dough out, but I must admit that I am out of practice and overall it was really easy.

The sour cream doesn't overwhelm the taste of the crust, if that's something you're worried about. I definitely could smell it while I was rolling out the dough, so I was expecting the crust to have a slight tang to it. But the sour cream really just melts into the crust for an even richer, more buttery flavor. Because the sour cream also has fat in it, it also helps you achieve a flaky, tender crust. Mine was super-flaky. I ended up making a quiche with it, and it was delicious.

This isn't just a hack to help your dough roll out easier; it also helps you get that dream pie crust texture (you know, all those baking buzzwords: buttery, flaky, and crispy). In the future, when I decide to make pie crust from scratch (I'm still not totally ruling out store-bought crusts), I will definitely be adding some sour cream to the mix.
Further Reading
Unlock Weekly Recipes You Won't Find Anywhere Else

I've Tested Nearly Every Piece of Induction Cookware on the Market. This Is a List of the Best of the Best.

We Tested 4 Famous Chocolate Cake Recipes and Found a Clear Winner

Sign up for The Kitchn's Daily newsletter to receive our best recipes, posts, and shopping tips in your inbox.

Source: yahoo.com