The officials gave Giants quarterback Jameis Winston a touchdown on a fourth-and-goal tush push today against the Jaguars, but on replay it’s not at all clear that Winston actually scored.
Winston dove into a mass of bodies, and his helmet appeared to touch the ground before the ball crossed the goal line. The officials signaled touchdown, and play was not stopped for a replay review, but former NFL referee Gene Steratore said on the CBS broadcast that it did not appear to be a touchdown.
There wasn’t a perfect replay angle, and the Jaguars were called for offside on the play, so even if Winston had been ruled short, the Giants would have been given another chance. Still, it does appear that the Giants were given a touchdown they didn’t actually score.
The Giants have a 10-3 lead over the Jaguars at the start of the second quarter.